Build For Tomorrow
Subscribe
Cover photo

Here’s Why the Best Workers Leave Companies, While the Worst Ones Stay

A new study reveals a big problem with office obstacles.

Jason Feifer

Apr 22
15
11

Bad news for companies: Your best employees will not stand for your crap.

Even worse news for companies: Your worst employees absolutely will stand for your crap.

That’s basically the takeaway from an interesting new study out of the University of Iowa, and it has implications for every organization and its workers.

Let’s break it down.

Researchers surveyed 256 architects — which is to say, they talked to people who work in a stressful industry and serve persnickety clients. The researchers wanted to know things like: How proactive are these workers? How stressed are they? Do they face a lot of problems at the office, such as office politics, lack of resources, unclear roles, and other nonsense? And most importantly, are they thinking about leaving their job?

(By "proactive," the study authors mean workers who are self-starters, actively engaged in their work, and eager to step up and take on more responsibilities. In other words, the best kind of people you could have.)

The results were fascinating. The more a worker identified as proactive, the more likely they were to consider quitting jobs with dysfunctional office environments.

Less proactive workers were also frustrated by dysfunctional companies, but they weren’t as motivated to quit.

Which means they’ll just stick around and make the company worse.

Well, let’s start here: Have you ever worked at a place full of unmotivated, dull people? I won’t name names, but I sure have. My colleagues seemed to have little career ambition, and just waited around for someone to tell them what to do. I never knew how to connect with these people, and I also never stuck around long enough to figure it out.

It left me wondering: Why are some companies full of sharp and self-motivated teams, while others are bogged down by aimless clock-watchers?

The University of Iowa study offers at least a partial answer: It’s because when companies are full of office politics, red tape, and unclear directions, their most proactive employees will peace out! That’s a huge loss, because prior research has found that proactive employees do the best work, are the most creative, and are also the most helpful.

“That’s why maintaining an office or company culture plagued by obstacles is such a problem,” says Eean Crawford, an associate professor of management and entrepreneurship at the University of Iowa Tippie College of Business, who coauthored the study. “It’s a double-whammy. If our research is correct, then that kind of company is not only more likely to lose employees, but more likely to lose their most valuable employees.”

I asked Crawford how companies can avoid this fate, and he said the starting point is simple: “Our number one recommendation is to focus as much energy as possible on removing obstacles, especially for the most proactive employees.”

For example, managers should regularly ask things like, “What is getting in your way and how can I get rid of it?”

“This signals support which makes proactive employees less like to think about leaving,” Crawford says.

As I think back to my own unfulfilling work environments, this research seems to explain a lot. Those companies suffered from a lack of clear leadership and labyrinthine politics, which made me feel under-appreciated and unable to do my best work. And I wanted to do my best work — not just because I take pride in my work, but because I always saw jobs as springboards: They’re a place to learn, grow, and then leave in order to do something bigger.

If a job didn’t serve as a strong enough springboard, then it was just a weight around my feet. I wanted to get the hell out of there as fast as I could.

This research should serve as a warning for any company that wants to build great things. To start, you need a great team — which means creating a culture where great teams thrive.

Great people don't put up with crap. And they shouldn't have to.

_________________________________________

Like what you read? Subscribe and take control of your future.

🕵🏻‍♀️ Looking for more lessons to help you change? Check archives.

💌 What do you think? Let me know!

👋 Say hello on Instagram, Facebook or Twitter.

📕 Pre-order my book to become more adaptable in your career!

🎧 Latest podcast: Real Ways to Predict the Future

_________________________________________

Cover credit: Getty Images / Roger Wright

Subscribe for free to Build For Tomorrow
By subscribing, you agree to share your email address with Jason Feifer to receive their original content, including promotions. Unsubscribe at any time. Meta will also use your information subject to the Bulletin Terms and Policies
Like · 15
Comment · 11
Share

More from Build For Tomorrow
See all

This One Question Can Predict A Happy Relationship, According to Data Science

It's just as powerful in work and romance.
Today
1

Stuck Between Two Bad Options? You Need to “Knock the Flagpole Down”

A great decision-making strategy from the cofounder of Netflix.
May 17
1

Confirmed: Your 30-Minute Meetings Can Be Done In 15 Minutes

An experiment at Asana proves it.
May 13
2
2
Comments
Log in with Facebook to comment

11 Comments

  • Erik Walker
    The fact remains - we are all pawns in the profit machine. We are interchangeable cogs building THEIR future, not our own. This has been evident in the licensing process- even the "good" firms leave their interns in the dust. They stick them in a cl…
    See more
    • 3w
  • Michelle Wolfe
    Try being a teacher or a para - same thing, I was the latter. Oh you try to find the best way to teach or encourage your students, and you end up getting falsely accused of telling kids answers to tests or doing such a good job that they escort you ou…
    See more
    • 3w
  • Julie Muszynski
    I’ve worked for the same company for over 35 years and I would never call myself unmotivated. Sure I’ve seen some really great people leave but the majority that don’t stick around are not missed at all.
    • 3w
  • Kelly Minty Lenz
    I’ve left due to foolish people in high positions who couldn’t lead a team out of a paper bag. Their loyalty to the company supersedes what they actually bring to
    The table.
    • 3w
  • Andy Grant
    Good workers know they're worth, and so do employers. They leave for more money.. Simple. Rocket science, I know.
    • 3w
  • Les Todd
    Horrible right wing politics are in every industry now and its killing companies but top management is lied too and never hears about it. Good employees leave and it hurts the company. Then they move the company to China . In many cases it takes many m…
    See more
    • 3w
  • Martha Washington
    I took jobs with large national companies, figuring I would be nicely paid, opportunity for advancement....only to find them politically bogged down, no motivation and less pay. As the article said "peace out"
    • 3w
  • Les Todd
    The Biggest problem is the people at the top are being lied too by lower management that allows the politics to go on .
    • 3w
  • Zachary Henning
    This article is full of subjective fluff with no actual facts. Even the study mentioned has no references which most "real" articles would do.
    • 3w
  • Chris Myers
    Most of the time it's bad managers why people leave
    • 4w
    • Edited
View 1 more comment
Share quoteSelect how you’d like to share below
Share on Facebook
Share to Twitter
Send in Whatsapp
Share on Linkedin
Privacy  ·  Terms  ·  Cookies  ·  © Meta 2022
Discover fresh voices. Tune into new conversations. Browse all publications